Friday, February 5, 2016

I'm Sorry, Can You See My Shoulders?

It is becoming increasingly apparent that there are some pretty big differences in the ways in which girls and boys are treated in school based on their gender and their clothing. Many schools have strict dress codes set in place, and although the language of these policies does not always specify female students, it often targets articles of clothing worn specifically by girls (leggings, skirts, tank tops, etc.). Many young women who wear such articles of clothing are frequently told that they are "distracting" the male students in their classrooms. This sends a clear message to both girls and boys that girls' bodies are dangerous and sexualized and that they are solely responsible for boys' actions toward them. 

I want to take a moment to clarify that I'm not saying that all school dress codes are sexist, or that anyone in violation of the dress code shouldn't be punished for breaking school policy. I think that if a school has a reasonable dress code set in place then there is no reason it shouldn't be followed. I am, however, saying that many of these dress codes exist for the wrong reasons. I think that it would be fair to say that a school dress code is sexist if it disproportionally targets girls, sexualizes young girls' bodies, or at all suggests that that it is these girls' fault for distracting boys.

One specific example of a school dress code that has gone too far happened earlier this school year in Kentucky when Stephanie Dunn got sent to the principle's office for wearing a shirt that did not cover her collar bone. Stephanie's mother, Stacie, was called in to pick her daughter up and criticized the school for such a ridiculous system: "Parents are being called away from their important jobs and students are missing important class time because they are showing their collarbones! Something needs to change!" Stacie Dunn also said in her Facebook post that it was ridiculous that the girls at that school weren't allowed to show their collar bones because it "may distract their male classmates." Stephanie's mother brought her a scarf to attempt to cover up in compliance with the school's dress code but was ultimately sent home anyway for giving the principal an attitude when he told her that the scarf was also (somehow) inappropriate. There is a potential for change within the school however. Stacie noted that the principle called her to set up a meeting, saying that he would be willing to reexamine the school's dress code if she would be willing to put together a proposed policy. 

This dress code controversy has prompted many young women to take a stand against their schools' sexist policies. They are starting movements like "Not 'A' Distraction", in which students in South Carolina wore scarlet A's to school in the style of Hester Prynne to highlight the harm done by enforcing misogynistic values on young women.  There is also the hashtag #IAmMoreThanADistraction which began in 2014 and has picked up momentum during this school year. Started by a group of girls from New Jersey, the group aims to draw attention to the fact that interrupting a girl's school day to have her sent home or change clothes sends a message that making sure that boys have a "distraction free" learning environment is more important than her own education. This hashtag has generated thousands of posts on social media and empowered other young women to speak out against the unfair and often sexist dress code guidelines enforced upon them.

Unfortunately, the policy of policing women on what they can and can't wear doesn't stop in high school. The over-sexualization of women in the workplace is also a growing problem in our society and can be traced directly back to school dress codes: if girls are policed and sexualized at an early age, that impacts what both girls and boys grow up to view as the social norm. 

10 comments:

  1. Laura, I love your topic- I'm so sick of people saying that feminism isn't an issue anymore, or that we should be happy with our status because at least we aren't living in the dismal environment for women's rights in other countries. I also completely relate to your post- one time in middle school a male vice principal told my whole class that if you wear a V-neck shirt to school, don't complain when boys look down your shirt because "that's what boys do." It's unbelievable to me that people get away with saying stuff like that to impressionable youth. Thanks so much for sharing your take.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The topic of your blog is important and definitely needed. So many people view feminism as the wrong thing and I think this will open the eyes of some people. This specific topic would cause major issues at my high school because many people didn't agree with the policies in place.

    Thanks for sharing :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can relate 100 percent to this post, at my high school it seemed that the dress code only applied to the girls. One time my basketball team and myself all wore nice business skirts that were long but a bit on the tight side. One of the teachers told on us, and we all got detention. The sad part is half the boys in my school would wear pants that didn't cover their bottoms.... It still infuriates me to this had. I look forward to reading more of your posts.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Strong post. There were a couple of teachers back at my high school that many students would avoid just to be able to wear more of what they wanted. Most of them were girls, and it's truly unjust to have to alter your schedule or even just your path to your locker because of a dress policy. Quite honestly, it's barbaric and teachers should be more focused on other things. Nice background, too.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Strong post. There were a couple of teachers back at my high school that many students would avoid just to be able to wear more of what they wanted. Most of them were girls, and it's truly unjust to have to alter your schedule or even just your path to your locker because of a dress policy. Quite honestly, it's barbaric and teachers should be more focused on other things. Nice background, too.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really like this post. Even as a guy I realized how ridiculous and restricting my high school dress code was for girls. I would watch all of my female friends try to make their shorts appear longer than they were or try to cover up their shoulders whenever the security guard came by. To me that is just causing unnecessary stress for girls.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great post! My school actually had this issue and started a campaign with guys and girls all wearing tank tops one day to class. It was interesting to watch unfold. While reading your blog, I was wondering if this is as national of a problem as we think or just appears to be since we see it so much. Also, your point about the workforce is interesting. I hadn't thought of that and wonder as women desire to rise in "a man's world" this impacts the way they dress, less and less "feminine" so to speak.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree completely that dress codes can be quite sexist, and that the codes should be much more relaxed. At my school there were strict rules for guys as well for the same reasons. If a guy were to wear a tank top, it would be very distracting to a girl, and is thus banned for the same reason. However the rules for girls are much more strict and should be relaxed as girls are of course more than a distraction.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I consider myself to be a neutral feminist; a term that is often pushed away by the "true" feminists. I was really interested in reading your post because so many people define feminism in different ways, which often times they are not all given credit. I was interested to see what your first conflicting issue of discussion. This was a strong post and I look forward to reading more.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The way you phrase the question, is a male's distraction-free learning environment worth more than a female's education, is very powerful. It gets to the heart of some outrageous dress code policies because calling shoulders, collarbones, etc. "distracting," is absurd. I believe in the argument that it's guys who should be educated if they can't focus because of a girl's shoulders. Are they afraid that if we wear tank tops to class our bra straps will show and then all concentration is lost? It's very frustrating. Anyway, great first post!

    ReplyDelete