For this week's blog post, I have decided to explore a topic that has recently garnered a lot of attention on social media. This is a slightly controversial topic not only in our society but even within the feminist community. That is why this week I would like to address the question, is makeup a feminist issue?
Recently on social media, there has been a picture of a woman with and without makeup on that has been circulating with the caption "this is why you should take a girl swimming on the first date." The image features Ashley VanPenevage, a 20 year old college student from Tacoma, Washington. VanPenevage, who was suffering from an allergic reaction to a medication, asked a friend to help her cover up her acne and posted a before and after picture to Instagram. The picture was then picked up by several Twitter accounts and shared using captions suggesting women "falsely advertise" themselves when they wear makeup.
I would like to start off by pointing out that people are not products to advertise. Saying that implies that women who wear makeup (or really anyone who does for that matter) are selling themselves. That's just simply not the case; women are not a product to be purchased. I don't think that wearing lipstick can be classified as misrepresenting yourself. Sure, of course women look different with makeup on, some more so than others. But that doesn't mean that these women are "lying" about what they look like, that's just simply what they look like with makeup on! And lets be honest, if you think that women naturally have bright red lips or sparkly eyelids, you might have to reevaluate some of your perceptions.
This one example brings us to a much larger issue. Is wearing makeup really a woman's choice to make? Or does society make that decision for us? Many feminists believe that the reason women wear makeup is because our culture tells us that we look bad without it. I think that this is true to a certain extent. Women wearing makeup has become a standard in American society. Think about it--when was the last time you saw an advertisement or a TV show in which a woman was not wearing any makeup? According to writer Jenna Sauers, makeup is "so ever-present in our lives that women who don't wear makeup are commonly taken as defining themselves against it. To not wear makeup, for many women, is to invite misunderstanding or, worse, judgement." In her Jezabel article, Sauers also doubts the existence of women who "wear makeup for themselves."
While I do agree with Sauers that wearing some amount of makeup has become a standard in our society, I don't agree that there aren't any women out there who don't wear makeup just because they want to. Personally, I like to wear makeup for myself. Now, I guess you could argue that I'm kidding myself and that the real reason that I wear makeup is because society says that I should or that I'm trying to please men or whatever other reasons people have come up with. But the truth is that there are some days that I wear a full face of makeup and other days that I don't put anything on at all, and my deciding factor is simply how I'm feeling that day and whether or not I have the time. I don't believe that anyone's beauty or self worth has anything to do with the amount of makeup they wear.
So as I'm wrapping up my post, I'd like to definitively answer my initial question. Yes, makeup is a feminist issue, but maybe not for the reasons you initially thought. About a year ago, Buzzfeed made a video that explored the question, "Can It Be Feminist to Wear Makeup?" In response to the video, Bustle writer Carlo Chauvet wrote that "being feminist means ultimately asking the why behind actions that could be perceived as ways women objectify themselves and submit to patriarchal culture. Judging a woman for wearing makeup because it makes her feel good is just [as bad] as criticizing her habit of putting on makeup solely based on her lack of self-esteem or desire to please men." The video in question emphasizes the choice that women make for themselves when they decide either to wear makeup or not to. And with all of the grief that women get for both wearing makeup and not wearing makeup, how could their decision have anything to do with anything but their own opinion?
First of all -- I love the title of your post. It's not obvious until you read your first paragraph, and then I was like ohhhhh. But anyway, I agree with you. I also wear makeup for myself, as does my sister (whose fault it is that I now have a ridiculous amount of Colourpop lippie stix). But makeup is art for your face. Just looking at makeup, it's beautiful, in my opinion. So I'm on the side of makeup for your own pleasure, not anyone else's.
ReplyDeleteThis is a really interesting post. I've always thought about the "take a girl swimming" thing. While a bit silly for some people it is so true. For some, especially the ones who pile on makeup everyday no matter the occasion, the makeup acts to me as a way for them to hide or change who they are. I don't really like this. I can't really explain my whole logic behind this.
ReplyDeleteLaura, I think you did a great job of framing this issue in a clear way by relating it to your own life. There are definitely many different reasons that women choose to wear makeup, but I agree that it's ridiculous to say that women can't wear it for themselves.
ReplyDeleteThere seems to be a lack of middle ground between women wearing makeup to conform and women not wearing makeup to rebel, which isn't a good thing. As a girl who wears makeup whenever its convenient, I don't like this dichotomy either.
ReplyDeleteI think that your topic for today is extremely interesting. I had always considered make-up to be a personal choice. Most people presumable aim to look nice in public for a variety of reasons, but society's standards as to what looks nice is different for men and women. As you said, I think that one should chose for herself as to whether or not makeup is the right choice for them.
ReplyDeleteI really liked this post!I usually wear makeup everyday, but its usually for me; nothing makes me more excited than buying a new color of lipstick to try. I usually wear it out of habit but as you said, I'm just as comfortable not wearing it.
ReplyDeleteI love that you say "people are not products to advertise." That is a great point because no matter what you look like, whoever is seeing your physical appearance isn't seeing your values or your personality right away. So really it's the people who are judging others by their appearance that need to change, not those who wear makeup for whatever reason they choose.
ReplyDelete